This article analyses the practical and theoretical process of structuring re- search fieldwork in a prison, and the specific research topics that it has led to shape. In 2011, my former research-assistant in Aceh, Indonesia, was sentenced to 20 years imprisonment for drug dealing. I subsequently carried out ethnography in the prison where she was detained, in the area of North Sumatra. My main argument concerns the relationship between a prison- er and the State as it is constructed before, during and after prison, and the subjective feelings and prison narratives which such relationship origi- nates. I shall question how the researcher can make sense of prison through the prisoners’ own efforts to that end. I shall analyse the hypertrophic role that the ethnographic vis-à-vis encounter plays when the research devel- ops in a restricted place and consider the “prison mind” as the totalisation of thoughts typical of incarceration. I shall conclude on the possibility of self-rescue that narratives of lived heterosexual love can provide the convict- ed women with, thus enabling them to tolerate or overcome “prison pain”. Conversely, I shall underline how such individualization of suffering also leads to obliterate the political weight of female criminal sentencing in a post-conflict, post-disaster social environment.
Vignato, S. (2020). Ethnography Inside: Female Imprisonment, “Prison Pain” and the Criminalization of the Acehnese in Indonesia. ANTROPOLOGIA, 7(2), 175-200 [10.14672/ada20201691175-200].
Ethnography Inside: Female Imprisonment, “Prison Pain” and the Criminalization of the Acehnese in Indonesia
Vignato, S
2020
Abstract
This article analyses the practical and theoretical process of structuring re- search fieldwork in a prison, and the specific research topics that it has led to shape. In 2011, my former research-assistant in Aceh, Indonesia, was sentenced to 20 years imprisonment for drug dealing. I subsequently carried out ethnography in the prison where she was detained, in the area of North Sumatra. My main argument concerns the relationship between a prison- er and the State as it is constructed before, during and after prison, and the subjective feelings and prison narratives which such relationship origi- nates. I shall question how the researcher can make sense of prison through the prisoners’ own efforts to that end. I shall analyse the hypertrophic role that the ethnographic vis-à-vis encounter plays when the research devel- ops in a restricted place and consider the “prison mind” as the totalisation of thoughts typical of incarceration. I shall conclude on the possibility of self-rescue that narratives of lived heterosexual love can provide the convict- ed women with, thus enabling them to tolerate or overcome “prison pain”. Conversely, I shall underline how such individualization of suffering also leads to obliterate the political weight of female criminal sentencing in a post-conflict, post-disaster social environment.File | Dimensione | Formato | |
---|---|---|---|
1691-4617-1-PB.pdf
accesso aperto
Tipologia di allegato:
Publisher’s Version (Version of Record, VoR)
Dimensione
1.51 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
1.51 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.